Woman responsible for a fatal accident is back behind bars

BEDFORD – Kasey L. Caraway, 50, of Bedford, is back behind bars after she violated the court’s order of her pretrial release. She was arrested on Tuesday, April 30.

She will appear before Lawrence County Superior Court Judge John Plummer III on May 22 at 9:00 a.m.

Kasey Caraway

Caraway is facing felony charges of operating a vehicle while intoxicated resulting in death, OWI endangerment, and operating a vehicle while under the influence of a controlled substance.

Caraway’s toxicology report was positive for codeine, fentanyl, morphine, Norfentanyl, amphetamines, and methamphetamine.

The three-vehicle accident occurred on Monday, February 6, 2023, at 11:44 a.m. at State Road 37 and John Williams Boulevard, claimed the life of 65-year-old Michael Wright of Bedford.

Before arrival, officers were advised that it was a fatal accident. Upon arrival, Bedford Police Major Jeremy Bridges noticed a vehicle damaged on its side and a car in the median with damage, as well as individuals standing near both vehicles.

Bridges then noticed a body covered with a blanket on the shoulder of the roadway. He checked on the body to confirm no lifesaving measures were needed. Once Major Bridges determined nothing could be done medically to help the man, Officers Clint Swanson and Derek Blackwell gathered information from the drivers and witnesses.

According to a Bedford police report, 65-year-old Michael Wright of Bedford was standing in front of his 1985 Jeep Wrangler, which was disabled in the left southbound lane of State Road 37. The hood to Wright’s vehicle was up, and he had his emergency flashers activated. However, another witness said there were no emergency flashers activated.

According to the police, Caraway was driving a 2005 Cadilac Escalade and struck Wright’s vehicle, which hit Wright, launching him into the air. Police say it appeared Caraway did not slow down or change lanes when her vehicle struck Wright’s Jeep.

Caraway told police she did not see the Jeep stopped in the travel portion of the road and could not avoid impact.

At the same time, 61-year-old Rebecca French, of Bloomington, was traveling in the right lane of State Road 37 in a 2013 Nissan Frontier and had swerved to miss debris from the accident and struck Wright, who was thrown into her path of travel.

According to the police report, all the drivers involved were given blood tests at IU Health Bedford Hospital to determine whether they were impaired, which is standard procedure in a fatal accident.


On 03-01-2024 I was advised that Driver, Kasey L. Caraway’s, toxicology report
had shown positive for Codeine, Fentanyl, Morphine, Norfentanyl, Amphetamine,
Methamphetamine.
Based upon the foregoing information, I have probable cause to believe
that Kasey L. Caraway committed the crimes of
Operating While Intoxicated Resulting in Death
Operating While Intoxicated Endangerment
Operating While Intoxicated (Controlled Substance)
X I request that an arrest warrant be issued for the arrest of the
Defendant(s) with bond to be set in a amount set forth in the Court’s bond
schedule for the offense(s) charged.